Skip to main content

Which is better: The Book or the Movie?

___________________________________________



I recently read Philip Pullman's "The Golden Compass" and am anticipating its arrival in the local dollar theater in a month or two. The one thing bothering me is the age old question, "which will be better; the book or the movie?"

I've experienced the same worry with a few pairs of books and feature-length films.

Book Winners:
-The Bible (Prince of Egypt)
-All Quiet on the Western Front
-Catch-22
-The Great Gatsby
-The Grapes of Wrath
-Of Mice and Men
-The Time Machine
-Charlotte's Web

(Classics)
-Jurrasic Park
-Timeline
-Misery


Movie Winners:
-The Borne Identity
-Dune
-The Princess Bride

(Classics)
-The Count of Monte Cristo
-Pride and Prejudice (I am akin to both the newer Kiera Knightley and Provo Remakes)


I'm sure I've seen more movies based on books I've read, but this is a suitable list to examine. What I see here is that I exhibit an affinity for classics in literature form. Apparently, the silver screen can never do justice to a book with such high expectations. I suppose if the movie came out first, it would be a differnt story. I can't think of any examples of this can you?

Comments

  1. NoelleThu Dec 13, 07:56:00 AM MST

    I also think it depends on which one you experience first/grow up with. When Phil and I went to see the play "Wait Until Dark" he liked the actress in the play far better than Audrey Hepburn. I couldn't stand her because she was far too brash and I loved Audrey Hepburn's portrayal of the blind woman in the movie. It's what I grew up with!!!

    I think P.Bride movie was better than the book.
    I also REALLY loved the movie adaptation of Much Ado (I think I saw it before I read the book and so those characters were in my brain when I read it.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. HeatherThu Dec 13, 01:02:00 PM MST

    I cannot think of a time when they wrote the movie after the book, except maybe Star Wars?
    Movies are def. better in that instance. I agree with Belle on Princess Bride movie being superior, as well as Much Ado - but that's because READING and INTERPRETING Shakespeare is much harder than enjoying somebody else's genius at doing it. I don't even count Pr & Prej as the same as the movie, and therefore can't decide which is better.
    Rick and I read all three of the Philip Pullman books and really enjoyed them. I don't anticipate the movie will do it justice.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Please share your thoughts.

Popular posts from this blog

Rummi-"CUB" vs. Rummi-"CUBE"

The "Rummikub" Pronunciation Debate Affirmative Constructive: "Cub" For years, I have been a firm advocate and defender of the pronunciation, Rummi-"CUB".  The game box I grew up with spelled it, Rummicub  on the box. However, other productions of the game have variant spellings: Rummykub , Rummy Kube , Rummy Tiles , etc.  Based solely on box spelling, the game's true pronunciation is open to interpretation. Therefore, Rummi"cub" is equally acceptable to any other given pronunciation. Negative  Constructive : "Cube" My opponents argue that since the game originated over seas, we ought to respect and maintain its original pronunciation. Affirmative Rebuttal: Americanization of the Term When the game was brought to America and given Americanized rules, its name was also Americanized. Pronunciation loyalists then counter my rebuttal with, "there are lots of adopted foreign words that have retained their original pron...
5 comments
Read more

The Secret Reason Why "Good Witch" Feels Emotionally Off

TL;DR It's the Botox. For the past 3 months, my wife, Stacia, and I have been watching  Good Witch  (via Netflix and Amazon Prime). Stacia adores winding down to "Hallmark-y shows." We can rely on Good Witch episodes to always resolve happily. The episodes are never too intense. The height of conflict revolves around things like someone's inability to locate the perfect spot to snap a romantic photo for a new tourism brochure. I consider my time watching these shows spouse bonding time , and emotional training. My favorite thing about watching feel-good shows with Stacia is getting to observe her facial reactions to the on-screen drama. When two people lean in for a long-anticipated kiss, Stacia tucks her knees into her chest and frowns with her forehead while lifting her chin and bottom lip. While I'm typically unable to suspend my disbelief, Stacia seems completely entranced by the various characters' emotions. Wishing I could join her in being swept aw...
4 comments
Read more

Who's Got The Funk?

I am an amateur guitarist, and I've got no funk. My musical skills seem to lacking that special something . Great musicians have it . Those fortunate enough to have gotten hold of  it , create timeless hits. While musicians without it  fade into oblivion. After spending hours searching through Blues history websites and 1970's band documentaries online, I discovered what that special something  is thank to a (70% Man, 30% fish) character from the BBC show "The Mighty Boosh" named Old Gregg. He identified that  thing  as  The Funk ! But what exactly is The Funk ? Here is some dialogue from the show to help explain its origin and purpose: Old Gregg: You're a musician, yeah? Howard: Yes I am. Old Gregg: Butchya ain't very good, are ya? Howard: I'm one of the best in town. Old Gregg: Come on, I read your reviews. Hmm? You know what your problem is? Howard: What? Old Gregg: Ya ain't got the funk. You're all rigid. Hmm? You're l...
2 comments
Read more